Who should be handling your creditability testing?

There are four realistic answers, and one of them is often the carrier. Here is how to work out which fits your situation.

Any of these sound familiar?

Answer four questions and see where you land.

Question 1 of 4

Funding

How is the medical plan funded?

Self-funded plans usually sit outside whatever testing a carrier performs, because there is no carrier plan design to test.

Part D determination comparison

How Creditable, the carrier, a third-party actuary and in-house testing compare across six criteria for Medicare Part D creditable coverage determinations.
CriteriaCreditableCarrierThird-party actuaryIn-house
1. AccuracySame method, every runVaries, not always testedHigh accuracyDepends who runs it
2. SpeedSame sessionDays to weeks, or lateTwo to six weeksSlow and manual
3. Cost$250 per plan, per plan yearIncluded, but limitedHigh per plan feeHigh internal labor cost
4. TransparencyMethod stored with every runLittle to noneReport providedLimited unless expert
5. ScalabilityEach design tested on its ownOne blanket statementPriced separately each timeTime consuming to scale
6. DocumentationA record, plus the noticeWhatever they send youA PDF reportA spreadsheet

Bring a plan you have already determined.

Run it through with us and compare the answer to the one you already have.